This mayo's thick and fatty taste and texture helped it climb toward the top, but the lack of umami flavor compared to Chosen Food's or Sir Kensington's plant-based mayos yielded no award.

Best Overall: JUST Mayo ($8) Editor's Pick: Follow Your Heart Original Vegenaise ($6.50) Best Flavored: Sir Kensington's Vegan & Keto Chipotle Mayonnaise ($10) Best Viral Sensation: Kewpie Vegan ...